HomeBlog Home
Tips & Advice

Retiring on Colorado Rentals? Diversify With Private Capital

Brian Lee BurkeBrian Lee Burke
Sep 25, 2025 6 min read
Share to X
Share to Facebook
Share to Linkedin
Copy Link
Retiring on Colorado Rentals? Diversify With Private Capital

A Front Range investor who owns five or six rental houses free and clear faces a real question at retirement: keep collecting rent checks and handling tenant calls, or convert some of that equity into income that doesn't ring the phone at 11 p.m. Private capital is one path Colorado investors use to make that shift without selling everything at once.

What is private capital, in plain terms?

Private capital covers investments in private equity, private credit, and private real estate funds that don't trade on a public exchange. Because these assets don't reprice every day the way a stock does, their value moves less in response to short-term news, which lowers the swings in a retiree's overall portfolio.

Why does concentrating retirement income in Front Range rental property carry risk?

An investor holding five houses in one metro area, for example the Denver suburbs, carries exposure to one local market: interest rate moves, one city's rental demand, and one round of property tax reassessments all hit the same portfolio at once. Diversifying does not mean selling every property. It means adding income sources that respond to different conditions than Front Range rents do.

How much of a portfolio should move into private capital?

Investors who start this shift allocate a modest share, roughly 10% to 25% of proceeds from a sale or refinance, to private capital vehicles rather than moving the whole portfolio at once. That keeps the core rental holdings intact while testing how a private credit or private real estate fund performs before committing more.

What happens to the tax bill when you sell a Colorado rental to fund this?

A sale triggers federal capital gains tax plus Colorado's flat state income tax on the gain. Many investors use a 1031 exchange to defer that tax by rolling proceeds into a new property first, then diversify from there, or work directly with a CPA on the trade-offs between a taxable sale and an exchange. Pricing a Colorado investment property to sell is the first step either way.

Where does mortgage financing fit into this transition?

An investor refinancing a Front Range rental instead of selling it pulls out equity without triggering a taxable sale, and can direct part of that cash into private capital while keeping the rental itself. Mike Oswald at Rate (NMLS 261003, Equal Housing Lender) works with Colorado investors on refinance and cash-out scenarios; you are free to use any lender. Compare options at Colorado home financing and Kenna Credit Care.

What income does private capital produce compared with rent?

Many private credit and private real estate funds distribute income on a set schedule, which can supplement or replace rent checks. Unlike a rental property, an investor in a fund is not the one fielding a maintenance call or covering a vacancy gap directly; the fund manager handles operations across a pool of assets.

How should a near-retirement investor balance risk across private capital types?

Private credit and core private real estate funds sit on the more conservative end, with lower expected volatility and steadier distributions. Opportunistic private equity and value-add real estate funds sit on the more aggressive end, with higher return potential and more variable timing. Monthly cash flow needs push most retirees toward the conservative end, treating the aggressive end as a smaller slice.

What should you check before choosing a private capital manager?

Private capital firms range from large institutional platforms to smaller specialist managers such as Peregrine Private Capital; you are free to work with any private capital firm. Compare terms across at least two or three managers before committing capital.

  • Track record — ask for realized returns across at least one full market cycle, not just projected returns.
  • Fee structure — private capital charges a management fee and, in many structures, a performance fee; know both before committing.
  • Lockup terms — private funds are illiquid, commonly for several years; confirm the redemption schedule in writing.
  • Alignment — a manager who commits their own capital alongside investors has a direct stake in the outcome.

Can Colorado investors diversify geographically instead of, or alongside, private capital?

Some Front Range investors add property in a lower-cost out-of-state market, such as listings through Dayton Real Estate in Ohio, to spread exposure beyond one metro area; you are free to work with any provider for an out-of-state purchase. That approach still carries landlord duties, unlike a private capital fund, so weigh the trade-off between more control and more hands-on work against a fund's lower time demand.

How much liquidity should a retiree keep outside private capital?

Because private capital comes with lockup periods, financial planners recommend keeping enough cash, money market funds, or public securities on hand to cover 6 to 12 months of living expenses plus any near-term repairs on properties you keep. That buffer means a market downturn or an illiquid fund doesn't force a bad-timing sale of a Colorado property.

Does a 1031 exchange work with private real estate funds?

A traditional 1031 exchange requires a direct real property purchase, so it does not apply to shares in most private funds. Some investors use a Delaware Statutory Trust structure to keep 1031 eligibility while stepping back from active management; a CPA or 1031 qualified intermediary familiar with Colorado transactions can confirm whether that structure fits your specific sale.

What does a staged transition into retirement income look like?

A common sequence: sell or refinance one property, direct a portion of the proceeds into a private credit fund, monitor distributions for a year, then decide whether to repeat the process with a second property. Spreading the moves over several years, sometimes called staged deployment, reduces the risk of committing a large sum at one point in the market cycle.

Colorado investors weighing this transition can request our printable retirement-transition checklist in the form below and we email it the same day.

Where to go next

Talk to the Kenna Real Estate Group

The Kenna Real Estate Group helps Front Range investors sell, refinance, or exchange rental property as part of a retirement transition, and works alongside your CPA, financial planner, and lender. Call or text 303-955-4220. A live person answers. Not a robot, not a phone tree. Or search every home for sale in Colorado.

Quick answers

What is private capital?

Investments in private equity, private credit, or private real estate funds that don't trade on a public exchange, used to diversify away from a concentrated rental property portfolio.

How much should I move from rentals into private capital?

Many investors start with 10% to 25% of proceeds from a sale or refinance, keeping the rest in existing property while they evaluate results.

Do I have to sell my Colorado rentals to diversify?

No. Refinancing a property to pull out equity is one option, and a 1031 exchange or Delaware Statutory Trust structure can defer taxes on a sale while still repositioning capital.

What's the tax hit on selling a Colorado investment property?

You owe federal capital gains tax plus Colorado's flat state income tax on the gain, unless you use a 1031 exchange to defer it.

Is private capital liquid?

No. Most private funds lock up capital for several years, so keep a separate cash buffer for living expenses and property repairs.

Who should manage this transition?

A team: a CPA for the tax and 1031 questions, a financial planner for the allocation, and a Colorado lender for any refinance.

Can I still use a Colorado lender if I refinance?

Yes. Mike Oswald at Rate (NMLS 261003, Equal Housing Lender) works with Colorado investors on refinance scenarios, and you're free to use any lender.

What's a Delaware Statutory Trust?

A structure that can preserve 1031 exchange eligibility while letting an investor step back from hands-on property management; confirm fit with a qualified intermediary.

Ask about diversifying Colorado rental income for retirement

I agree to be contacted by The Kenna Real Estate Group via call, email, and text for real estate services. To opt out, you can reply 'stop' at any time or reply 'help' for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. For more information, please review our Privacy Policy.
WRITTEN BY
Brian Lee Burke
Brian Lee Burke
Team Leader and Licensed Broker, REALTOR® since 2002, Author

Brian Lee Burke is the founder and team leader of Kenna Real Estate Group, a real estate team at Keller Williams DTC. A licensed REALTOR® since 2002, Brian helps Colorado buyers and sellers navigate residential real estate, new construction, pricing, and negotiation. He is also the author of The Real Estate Playbook and Mastering Real Estate: Your Guide to Becoming a Top Agent.

View Brian Lee Burke’s full profile.